Supreme Court to Hear Two Landmark Cases on Children's Protection Rights
Parental rights face unprecedented legal challenges as the Supreme Court prepares to hear two landmark cases affecting how families can protect their children from harmful content in schools and online.
The first case, Mahmoud v. Taylor, challenges Montgomery County, Maryland's elimination of parental notification and opt-out provisions for elementary school materials covering gender and sexuality. The curriculum requires children as young as 3-4 years old to participate in lessons that may conflict with families' religious beliefs, including exposure to terms like "intersex flag," "drag queen," and "leather."
When Christian, Jewish, and Muslim parents objected, school board members dismissed their concerns and compared them to "white supremacists." The Fourth Circuit Court ruled against the parents, stating they could discuss topics with children afterward. However, many religious families view protecting young children from premature exposure to certain concepts as a sacred obligation.
The second case, Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton, examines Texas House Bill 1181, which requires age verification for websites distributing "sexual material harmful to minors." The law allows various verification methods, including government ID or biometric data. While pornography industry groups challenge its constitutionality, Texas argues for the state's interest in protecting minors.
During oral arguments scheduled for January 15, 2025, justices indicated support for protecting children from online pornography, noting previous content filtering methods' inadequacy. Eighteen other states have passed similar laws, and religious organizations including the Southern Baptist Convention's ERLC support Texas's position through amicus briefs.
Both cases will significantly impact parents' ability to:
- Guide their children's moral and spiritual development
- Protect young minds from premature exposure to complex ideological concepts
- Maintain religious freedom in public education
- Safeguard children in digital spaces
A ruling on these cases is expected by June 2025, potentially strengthening child protection measures nationwide.
Gospel Fluency book cover design
Note: Author Joe Carter serves as a senior writer for The Gospel Coalition and associate pastor at McLean Bible Church in Arlington, Virginia.